We include a paper return form inside your package to fill out and include with your return.  Once your package is received we will ship out the new item or process the refund/store credit.

If you did not receive a return form or misplaced it, please send an email to:  sales@amishmadebelts.com  and we will email you a PDF return form to print off. There is no need to email us first before returning unless you have questions or need a return form.


HOLIDAY GIFTS: We have extended our return policy for gifts to help customers order sooner to ensure they receive their packages in time. Orders placed in October, November, or December 2021 may be returned in new condition on or before January 31, 2022.  We have been told by many shipping carriers to expect major delays in December so please order now to ensure you receive your items in time.  Last minute shopping is not a good idea this year with the labor and supply chain delays nationwide.  

We're bummed things didn't work out and you need to return your order. We offer a 30 days return period if you need to return your item(s) for a new size, store credit, or refund to your credit card.  All items must be in new condition to return. An easy to use return form is included in your package to setup the return.  All directions are on this form.  Simply fill out the form with your order number, name, and email and mail it back.

Our return policy is similar to eBay and other websites. Main bullet points are:

  • 30 day return period from date received if in NEW condition.
  • New size product is processed quickly or refund issued within a few days.
  • If new size, we cover the cost of the new product and shipping new item to you. Buyer is responsible for shipping products back to us.
  • If store credit to reorder something else, buyer is responsible for shipping back and will receive an email gift card for price paid less original S&H costs.
  • If refund, refund is less S&H costs and processed back to your original form of payment. Buyer is responsible for shipping back to us.

Please email us if you did not receive a return form in your package. A completed return form is required to process your return.  Email us if you do not have your order number for the return.  This can normally be found in your email confirmations.  If 30 days has gone by since your purchase, unfortunately your order is non returnable. We close out orders after 30 days like most online retailers. Items returned in used condition will be returned at buyers expense.

Please try on all items and contact us immediately if they do not fit.  Products that have been worn for long periods or marked up by holsters can not be returned. If your items condition is questionable please call us first before returning. Extra belt hardware is non returnable since they are sold at cost.

We offer a ONE TIME return of your items.  If you need help calculating your size, please contact us or ask questions before ordering.  Use your new belt as a reference point for the new size. There is a $15 fee if you need a second return to cover S&H costs.

U.S.A. Returns

Belt Sizing Exchanges

Our belt sizing directions work 99.5% of the time but if you have a sizing issue we offer a one time sizing exchange. Simply return the item with the included return form in your package and we will remake the new size belt and ship it to you free. Buyer is responsible for return shipping costs. We stock even sizes only.

Exchanges other than length issues, please see the store credit or refunds section below.

Store Credit

Sometimes the item you receive just doesn't meet your needs or is a different color then you thought. In this situation its best to do a store credit so you can reorder something else on our site. We are happy to speak to you and help you choose an item that will best fit your needs. Click the contact us link on the top bar to reach us.

Simply return your item to us using the return form included in your package and we will email you a gift card number to use on our store. This gift card can be gifted to a friend or used any time you would like.

The gift card amount is what you paid less original S&H costs. Buyer is responsible for return shipping costs. Store credits are non refundable.


If you would like to return your items for a refund, use the return form inside the package and check the refund box.  Refunds will go back to the original form of payment and are less S&H costs.  Please allow an average of 3-5 business days after we process the return for your bank to post it back to your account.  Some banks are quick and some take a while.  You will receive an email from us once we process it. Buyer is responsible for return shipping costs.

Directions to ship your item(s) back

Please return your items to the address listed on the return form. All items must be in new re-sellable condition.

Buyer is responsible for return shipping costs. We may use any shipping method you like but we recommend getting tracking on the package. Insurance and signature confirmation is not necessary unless you feel it to be. Shipping is non refundable. We cover the cost to remake and reship the new size belt if you are exchanging for size. Never do a "Return to Sender" as this could get lost in the mail and take months for us to receive back.

Packages returned without a return form, items that are not in new condition, or packages that are past the return policy will be returned at the customers expense. Please email us first if the condition is questionable. We understand there may be some minor marks from trying it on.

How to carefully pack up your items

Please ship your items in a box or padded envelope. You can reuse the same packaging if it's not torn up.  Please coil up the belt like it was shipped to you so the buckle is not touching the front of the belt. Place it in a plastic or zip style bag so its protected.  Please do not use tape or bands around the belt as those could damage the belt! If you removed the buckle, please reattach all hardware as you originally received it. Make sure the original keeper loop is on the belt if removed.

Once we receive your package

We normally process returns the next business day.  Our return facility will ship out the new belt once its process (you will not receive an email confirmation so please check your tracking to see when we received it).  Refunds and store credits are processed within 1-2 business days.

Your new order will be shipped free by USPS standard delivery. If you asked for a store credit, a long coupon code will be emailed to you once your return has been processed.  You would enter this code during checkout on the page you enter your shipping address.  

We triple check all items before they are shipped out but if you receive a defective product, please contact us so we can replace it for you.

Canada Returns
Due to high shipping rates, we do not offer free returns on orders shipped to Canada but do offer refunds less S&H.

Refund: You may return the items for a refund less original S&H costs. For example, if you paid $80 for the product and $23.99 for shipping, you will receive a $80 refund. Contact us for a return form and directions.